If my TL this week is anything to go by, merely observing that some hobbies appeal more to boys risks running afoul of the screaming harpies of tolerance. But a thousand accusations of misogyny can't change what's demonstrably true: girls, on average, aren't that interested in gaming, Star Wars, or superhero comics -- and boys, on average, aren't that interested in reading Harlequin romance novels.
(Notice I said on average. I'm well aware that there are exceptions. As I mention below, I happen to be one!)
Now are these general trends evidence of a problem that cries out for a solution? According to the aforementioned harpies, yes: if a particular cultural product is not currently landing with most of the female audience, they say, it's insufficiently inclusive and must be reshaped. But my reply to such blather is really quite simple: why? Why does everything on Earth have to be rendered "friendly to women"? Why does everything have to cleave to your preferences? Why, exactly, are you entitled to be catered to no matter where you go?
That's certainly not how I entered Marvel comics fandom. I've gobbled up a ton of old Iron Man and Avengers comics because I like them as they are. I care not a whit that they were written for someone who is not me (i.e. the middle-American teenaged boy). As a matter of fact, I have so far been deeply unimpressed with Marvel's recent attempts to pivot in what the company assumes is my direction. No: I felt welcome already -- even if I am one woman in a crowd of men. And I suspect this is because I haven't asked for the entire fandom to revolve around me.
I honestly don't understand the self-centered insecurity that drives SJW feminists to colonize male-dominated fandoms and then demand they change. If you really like these "boy things," why are you trying to make them something they manifestly are not? To my mind, it would be much healthier - and far less annoying - if you simply owned your own gender nonconformity and relaxed with your bad selves. "Yep," you should say. "I'm a chick who reads male power fantasies/watches pew-pew movies/plays first-person shooter games. You got a problem with that?" Based on my personal experience, most of the men you'll be hanging with will respond with a hearty "no, ma'am!"
/my $.02.
It's not a woman thing-- it's probably an egotist thing, or some of the nastier related world-view errors.
ReplyDeleteI suspect it's also partly envy.
In real life, there's two responses to seeing something another person has that's really cool.
You can go: that's cool! I want that! Can I make something like that? (inspiration)
Or you can go: that's cool! I want that! Give it to me. (Envy.)
I very much lack sympathy for one of those, since it usually means nobody gets the cool stuff.
Women are, on average, very easy to browbeat into silence if you tell them that this or that was done for them. A significant number will also be outraged at any woman who, told that, says "but I don't want it." Regardless of if the outraged woman agrees that it isn't what she wanted. So you have an easy target with built-in enforcers on top of those who actually do want whatever you're pushing, and it's a huge population.
ReplyDeleteThus, very good choice as a group to declare you are doing things "for."
Your experience was the same as mine. When I found the guys who played D&D it felt like coming home. One boy's mom gave me a quizzical look and said "I did not know girls did this thing-?" But I was always welcomed.
ReplyDeleteUnlike the mean girls who bullied me mercilessly for being a freak (In all fairness, I was.) And now that gaming is a multi-million dollar industry, hey-o! Time to bully the freaks, and appropriate their culture.
And now that gaming is a multi-million dollar industry, hey-o! Time to bully the freaks, and appropriate their culture.
DeleteBingo.
The "fake gamer girl" blow-up came about exactly because it stung a lot of the folks who wanted to be the super special worshiped one for being a girl, even though they were acting like mean girls.
I've gotten a lot more wrongfans having wrongfun junk from imported authorities than I have from other geeks, which is impressive given how geeks tend to love their systems.